The clinic’s management objected, explaining to her that given the nature of the pediatric practice and the reasonable desire of child patients and parents to see the face of the medical staff providers, it could not approve wearing of a full headpiece. [the company] to assume that since the plaintiff was a Muslim it was obvious that he could not touch pork.” 2007 U.
Management told the employee however, that it would consider what reasonable accommodations could be made to its dress code policy.
According to the EEOC’s Complaint, the hospital terminated the physician because she requested as an accommodation, reducing her 12 hour shift to eight hours because fatigue contributed to her epileptic seizures.
He even offered to come in early or stay late to make up for any lost time. In the California case the store manager had made a note on the interview form that the young woman did not have that All-American “Abercrombie look.” Abercrombie, of course, is no stranger to litigation over its “Look Policy.” , No. On this campus, more than 10 percent of the students are Muslims, and as part of the ritual ablutions required before their five-times-a-day prayers, some were washing their feet in the sinks. After discussions with the Muslim Students’ Association, the university announced that it would install $25,000 foot-washing stations in several bathrooms. Nationwide, more than a dozen universities have foot baths, many installed in new buildings. But after a Muslim student at Minneapolis Community and Technical College slipped and hurt herself . “After the column, a Christian conservative group issued an action alert to its members, which prompted 3,000 e-mail and 600 voice messages to me and/or legislators,” said Phil Davis, president of the college. Universities Install Foot Baths for Muslim Students,” It did not help plaintiff’s case that none of the other Muslim employees in the plant appeared to have held the religious views that plaintiff held regarding touching pork.
The employer, citing potential violation of the collective bargaining agreement and impact on the morale of the other drivers, rejected the driver’s suggested accommodation, proposing that he instead bid on evening shifts that would not conflict with his prayer obligations. 8, 2008) when the EEOC obtained a consent decree from a Minnesota chicken processor adding a paid break during the second half of each shift to accommodate the religious beliefs of Muslim employees who wish to pray in the course of the work day. But as a legal and political matter, that solution has not been quite so simple. On some campuses, like George Mason University in Fairfax, Virginia, and Eastern Michigan Uni-versity, in Ypsilanti, Michigan, there has been no outcry . Davis said that after a legal briefing, the board con-cluded that installing foot baths was constitutional and that the college hoped to have a plan in place by the next school year. As the court noted, “the evidence is that the other Muslim employees made no such assertions to .
Before it could do so plaintiff resigned and filed a lawsuit against the clinic. The department determined that doing so would violate the department’s uniform regulation, which prohibited officers in uniform from wearing religious dress or symbols, applied in all circumstances, permitted no medical or secular exceptions. [the department’s] uniform as a symbol of neutral government authority, free from expressions of personal religion, bent or bias.” points up the difficulties faced by Muslim employees seeking accommodations to permit them to attend Friday prayers at local mosques. 2004) (class action settled for $50 million; plaintiffs alleged that Abercrombie’s “Look Policy,” the company’s conception of “natural, classic American style,” epitomized by a “good-looking” sales force, unlawfully excluded African-Americans and Hispanics from selling jobs).
The employer argued that plaintiff had neither given it sufficient time to consider her accommodation request nor provided enough information about her request for a reasonable accommodation to be made be-fore she resigned. Moreover, the commissioner testified that in his professional judgment and experience “it is critically important to promote the image of a disciplined, identifiable and impartial police force by maintaining . Plaintiff, a truck driver, asked his employer to permit him to add his coffee break to his lunch so that he could attend congregational Friday services and return to work on time. noted, When pools of water began accumulating on the floors in some bathrooms at the University of Michigan-Dearborn, and the sinks began pulling away from the walls, the problem was easy to pinpoint. while washing her feet in a sink, word got out there that the college was considering installing a foot bath, and a local columnist accused the college of a double standard – stopping a campus coffee cart from playing Christmas music but taking a different attitude toward Islam.
No pork accommodation is far from a certainty, however. The court summarily dismissed his suit, holding that the cost of accommodating plaintiff’s request to remain in the sanitation position would cause the em-ployer to suffer undue hardship.