For every match made, the finalist(s) with the correct answer moved up one space.The first finalist to reach the winner's circle where the Picker is standing won the date with him/her.
This was where the remaining players got involved in that question, and the Picker chose who to keep.
This round ended when three contestants were "kept", or enough players were "dumped" to leave three.
If there's a tie (two or all three finalsts made it), one final question with a numerical answer was asked to the tying contestants, such as "How many girls did (Picker's name) say he dated last year?
"; the contestant with the closest guess without going over won the date.
The contestant who received that ticket automatically advanced to the next round.